Advancing Together
Transcripción
Advancing Together
Advancing Together THE NEWSLETTER OF THE INTERNATIONAL LAND COALITION CONTENTS Editorial ....................................................................................................1 Land Coalition News .................................................................................2 Policy and Advocacy Praia + 9, Mali, 17-21 November 2003 ........................................................2 EU Consultation on Land Policy ...................................................................2 Land Coalition at ECOSOC in Geneva...........................................................3 Programmes Community Empowerment Facility 5th Project Aadvicory Committee meeting....4 Land Partnerships for Access to Land in South-East Asia ...............................4 Women’s Access to Land Rural Women’s Access to Land and Property in Selected Countries..................5 Coalition Partners Work Together to call for Access for Women Farmers ..........5 Land, Water and Gender in Southern Africa..................................................5 Workshops and Conferences Encuentro Internacional Campesinas y Sociedad Civil ....................................6 Regional Conference on Land and the Economy in Nicaragua November 2003 ..7 Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues Workshop at IFAD 15 Dec 03.............7 Land Issues in PRSPs LandNet West Africa October 2003 Lome Togo...............8 Territorio y Desarrollo sostenible en América Latina y Caribe junio 2003 ..........8 News from Coalition Partners SDF Workshop to Strengthen Participation of Women in Developmental Work ..9 TWA/ALRD Challenges and Lessons Learned in securing access to forest land. 10 Land Coalition Publications and Website................................................. 12 EDITORIAL Welcome back to Advancing Together, the newsletter of the International Land Coalition and its global network of partner organizations. In re-launching this newsletter for 2004, the Land Coalition hopes to provide a forum in which organizations and institutions working on land issues can share news and information on their efforts to increase access to land by poor men and women. As many readers know, the International Land Coalition was formed in 1995 (then known as the Popular Coalition) as an alliance of civil society, governments and intergovernmental organizations dedicated to improving secure access to land and other key assets and natural resources. Over the past nine years, our partners around the world have undertaken to find new ways of working together to achieve this mission, recognizing that the global challenges of hunger and poverty are too great for any one sector or institution to address on its own. The reasons for improving access to land are compelling. Poverty reduction, sustainable natural resource management, conflict prevention, food security and production, and rural and urban growth and migration are all closely related to land. Often, powerful vested interests stand in the way of change. Fortunately, possibilities for change are emerging, as policy-makers increasingly understand the consequences of neglecting poor men and women and denying them access to productive assets and resources. The Coalition’s secretariat, hosted in Rome by the International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD), serves as a focal point for communication among organizations with diverse interests, missions and, at times, ideologies. This diversity of opinions and approaches is what makes the character of the Land Coalition unique, and what offers us opportunities to encourage and support new models of partnership within and across sectors. The Coalition hopes that, as in our other collective efforts, Advancing Together will allow our partners and other organizations to share sustainable development experiences, and to strengthen our joint commitment to improve land access by poor men and women. We would welcome the submission of articles, editorials, letters or other comments, to make this effort as fruitful as possible. La Coalición para el Acceso a la Tierra espera que el esfuerzo colectivo generado por este boletín informativo, Avanzando Juntos, pueda brindar espacios para compartir con los partners y las otras organizaciones experiencias de desarrollo sustentable y para fortalecer nuestro compromiso en incrementar y facilitar el acceso a la tierra para los y las sin tierras. Serán bienvenidos artículos, editoriales, cartas y otros comentarios para poder hacer este esfuerzo lo más provechoso posible. La Coalition espère que, en tous nos efforts collectifs, Advancing Together permettra à nos partenaires et aux autres organisations de partager des expériences de développement durable, et de renforcer notre engagement collectif pour améliorer l’accès à la terre des pauvres. Nous vous invitons, donc, à soumettre des articles, des éditoriales, des lettres ou d’autres remarques, pour permettre à cet effort d’être vraiment fructueux. International Land Coalition www.landcoalition.org – Advancing Together Newsletter No 1 Vol 1 February 2004 1 Advancing Together COALITION NEWS / POLICY AND ADVOCACY Secretariat Retreat - Sep 03 The staff of the secretariat of the Land Coalition held a two-day planning retreat from 29-30 September 2003. During the retreat they discussed the implementation strategy and identified key efforts and activities related to the decisions on priority areas and thrusts that were made by the Assembly of Members in February 2003. Strategic Thrusts: • Documenting and sharing knowledge • Building networks and collective empowerment • Creating spaces for dialogue • Advocacy • Demonstration and integration • Coalition building Priority areas: • Governance • Communication • Resource mobilisation • Building country perspective • Monitoring and evaluation • Secretariat capacity has been a member of the Land Coalition since its foundation. La Coalición Internacional para el Acceso a la Tierra tiene el agrado de anunciar la llegada de Fernando Eguren a la Secretaria en Roma, para un periodo de cinco meses. Fernando es el presidente de una prestigiosa y comprometida ONG peruana, CEPES – Centro Peruano de Estudios Sociales. Fernando brindará a la Secretaria conocimientos y experiencias para consolidar el trabajo de la Coalición en la región latinoamericana, construir iniciativas de intercambios entre distintas regiones y apoyar en la gestión operativa e institucional de la Coalición. CEPES es miembro de la Coalición desde cuando esta ha sido creada. Land Coalition Council – Oct 03 The 2nd Session of the International Land Coalition Council was held in Rome from 6-7 October 2003. At the meeting, an update on programmes and activities was presented and issues related to governance, resources and monitoring and evaluation were discussed. Furthermore the Strategic Plan 2004-2006 was examined. In order to strengthen and clarify the plan the two main objectives and the strategic thrusts were identified. Main objectives: Secretariat at the retreat from left to right Lucia Angelucci, Andrew Fuys, Barbara Codispoti, Charlotte Pedersen, Jing de la Rosa, Alessandra Goberti, Bruce Moore and Annalisa Mauro Welcome Fernando Eguren The Land Coalition is pleased to announce that Fernando Eguren will join the Secretariat in Rome for a period of five months. Fernando is the president of a prestigious and committed Peruvian NGO CEPES (Peruvian Centre for Social Studies). He will bring the Secretariat knowledge and expertise to consolidate the Land Coalition’s work in the Latin American region, build initiatives to exchange knowledge with other regions and support the Land Coalition institutional and operational management. CEPES 1 2 Enhance capacities of members and partners securing access to land its in Facilitate the opening of spaces for dialogue Strategic thrusts: • Build the capacities of Land Coalition members and partners towards improving land tenure, securing support services and enhancing rural poor’s participation in decision-making through activities such as documentation/ sharing/upscaling and replication, building networks and capacity building on advocacy. • Facilitate the opening of spaces for dialogue through efforts to build spaces (i.e. LAND Partnerships), advocacy on, i.e., land tenure, support services and people’s possibly Watch. participation, establish a and Land • Maintain a country perspective bearing in mind the different political and social settings. The next session of the Council is anticipated for June 2004. POLICY AND ADVOCACY Praia+9, Mali, 17-21 Nov 03 Last November the International Land Coalition participated in the Regional Forum on Rural Land Tenure and Sustainable Development in the Sahel and West Africa (Regional Forum Praia+9). Attended by approximately 200 participants from government, donor agencies, NGOs and intergovernmental organisations, the Forum was organised by Permanent Interstates Committee for Drought Control in Sahel (CILSS) in Bamako. It defined new policy guidelines for the sub-region for the next decade to strengthen secure and equitable access to land resources and sustainable management of natural resources, including strategic orientations towards a subregional charter on rural land tenure. LandNet West Africa played an important role during the Forum having Mr Hubert Ouedraogo, Coordinator of LandNet West Africa, as the main rapporteur of the Forum. A copy of the proceedings and report from the Forum can be found on the CILSS website: www.cilssnet.org In support to the follow up of the Togo LandNet West Africa SubRegional meeting, the Land Coalition provided technical assistance to LandNet West Africa in organising a Side Event on Networking in West Africa. The Side Event was well attended and generated much interest among West African institutions to organise networking activities around land issues. International Land Coalition www.landcoalition.org – Advancing Together Newsletter No 1 Vol 1 February 2004 2 Advancing Together POLICY AND ADVOCACY Electronic Consultation on Draft EU Land Policy Guidelines In February, the Land Coalition launched a four-week electronic consultation on the Draft Land Policy Guidelines of the European Union (EU). These guidelines aim to establish a common framework for the design and support of land policy programmes by the EU and its member states. This consultation, now underway, seeks to provide civil society organizations and other intergovernmental agencies an opportunity to provide comments and recommendations to the European Commission (EC). The EC is one of the Coalition’s founding members, and is currently one of 14 organizations represented on the Coalition’s governing body, the Coalition Council. If your organization would like to participate in the consultation process, please email the secretariat at [email protected] before 12th March 2004. More information about the consultation, including copies of the EU Draft Policy Guidelines, can also be accessed at www.landcoalition.org. The Draft Guidelines are available in English, French and Spanish. Consultation électronique sur la version préliminaire des lignes directrices de politique foncière de l’Union européenne En février, la coalition Internationale pour l’accès à la terre a lancée une consultation de quatre semaines sur la version préliminaire des lignes directrices de politique foncière de l’Union européenne (UE). Ces lignes directrices ont pour bout la création d’une structure commune pour concevoir et supporter les programmes de politique foncière dans l’Union européenne et ses états membres. Cette consultation cherche de fournir aux organisations de la société civile et aux autres agences intergouvernementales une opportunité de fournir des commentaires et des recommandations à la Commission européenne. La Commission européenne est une des membres fondateurs de la Coalition, et actuellement est une des 14 organisations qui sont représentées dans la structure administrative de la Coalition, le Conseille de la Coalition. Si votre organisation veule participer au processus de consultation, envoyez-vous une email au secrétariat à la suivante adresse [email protected] avant le 12 mars 2004. Des informations additionnelles, y compris des copies de la version préliminaire des lignes directrices de politique foncière de l’Union européenne, peuvent être consultées à la page www.landcoalition.org. La version préliminaire des lignes directrices de politique foncière de l’Union européenne est disponible en anglais, français et espagnol. Consulta electronica sobre el borrador de las directrices de la política agraria de la Unión Europea (UE) En febrero, la Coalición Internacional para el Acceso a la Tierra ha convocado una consulta electrónica de cuatro semanas sobre el borrador de las Directrices de la Política Agraria de la Unión Europea. Estas directrices tienen como fin establecer un marco común para la UE con miras a apoyar, por conducto de la Comisión y los programas bilaterales de los Estados Miembros, la formulación de los procesos de reforma de la política agraria en los países en desarrollo. El objetivo de la Coalición no sólo es incluir en el proceso a la sociedad civil y a los miembros intergubernamentales, sino también conocer la opinión de la sociedad civil en su conjunto. La Comisión Europea fue uno de los fundadores de la Coalición y es una de las 14 organizaciones que actualmente forma parte del Consejo de la Coalición, es decir, su órgano rector. Si su organización quesería participar al proceso consultivo puede enviar un correo electrónico a la dirección siguiente: [email protected] para el 12 de marzo de 2004. Informaciones adicionales, incluyendo las copias del borrador de las directrices de la política agraria de la Unión Europea en ingles, español y francés pueden encontrarse en la pagina web de la Coalición www.landcoalition.org Land Coalition at the United Nations Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC) in Geneva 1 July 2003, Geneva Ministerial level government representatives, intergovernmental and civil-society Land Coalition partners attended the ECOSOC High-Level Ministerial Breakfast Roundtable Discussion on Land Use Practices and their Impact on Rural Development convened by the International Land Coalition, in conjunction with IFAD (International Fund for Agricultural Development) The Roundtable provided an opportunity for the participants to deliberate in-depth the topic of land use practices, land access and their importance to rural development. The exchange of experiences and perspectives on these topics provided a valuable contribution to the promotion of an integrated approach to rural development for poverty eradication and sustainable land use which was a critical consideration for the 2003 Substantive Session of ECOSOC. It was stated that the International Land Coalition is a mechanism that can assist governments to engage in participatory processes and to help governments open more space for stakeholder dialogue. Issues Paper and Summary of the Proceedings are available on our website. 27 June 2003, Geneva The Land Coalition collaborated with the Conference of NGOs (CONGO) to bring Land Coalition partners in Geneva to participate at the NGO Forum prior to ECOSOC. Four partners took part from Guatemala (Byron Garoz International Land Coalition www.landcoalition.org – Advancing Together Newsletter No 1 Vol 1 February 2004 3 Advancing Together PROGRAMMES from Coordinación de ONG y Cooperativas), Philippines (Don Marquez from Asian NGO Coalition for Agrarian Reform and Rural Development), Uganda (Harriet Busingye from Uganda Land Alliance) and Zimbabwe (Abby Mgugu from Women’s Land and Water Rights in SADC). Land Coalition partners provided presentations during the panel discussions and debates highlighting the importance of access to land for integrated rural development. The summary report prepared by CONGO is available from: [email protected] 29 June 2003, Geneva The Land Coalition and IFAD jointly convened a workshop, in collaboration with Women’s Environment and Development Organization and the Platform on Women’s Land and Water Rights in SADC, on the linkages between land, water and gender issues the outcome of which was 13 points of recommendations to the High-Level Segment of ECOSOC. The emergence of discussing the inter-connections is seen as an important step for both sectors to work together. A copy can be found on our website: www.landcoalition.org PROGRAMMES Community Empowerment Facility (CEF) 5th Project Advisory Committee Meeting On 8th October 2003, the 5th Project Advisory Committee for the Community Empowerment Facility Programme met in Rome to evaluate projects. The committee was comprised of three civil society members: Mr Don Marquez – Asian NGO Coalition for Agrarian Reform and Rural Development; Mr Ignace Coussement - International Federation of Agricultural Country BOLIVIA BOLIVIA Producers; Mr Menotti Bottazzi - Secours Populaire Francais; and two Inter-Governmental organisations: Mr Paul Munro-Faure - Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations; and Ms Sheila Mweanundu International Fund for Agricultural Development. Mr John Bruce from the World Bank participated as an observer. The committee approved the following seven projects. Organisation Centro de Investigación, Promoción y Desarrollo de la Ciudad FUNDACION TIERRA Title Recuperación de tierras agrícolas en la ribera del rio arque para mejorar la seguridad alimentária de los agrícultores de las cooperativas agricolas del municipio de Sicaya. Winning back cultivable lands along the banks of the River Arque to enhance the food security of farmers working in rural cooperatives in the Municipality of Sicaya. Difusión en Bolivia de la Plataforma común para el acceso a la tierra - construcción de escenarios de dialogo entre sectores involucrados en la problemática rural A Common Platform on Access to Land in Bolivia – Creating spaces for dialogue in sectors involved in rural questions. CAMEROON BIRDLIFE Promoting participatory natural resource management by indigenous communities in Ngovayang Forest. CHILE ANTU Proyecto Campesinos sin tierra de los fundos Tilama, Los Condores, Panguesillo, Tambo. Tahuinco, Bellavista - El Almendro, El Durazno y San Pedro de Quiles de la Cuarta Región de Coquimbo. Securing land access to previously settled peasants. Federación Nacional de Cooperativas Agropecuarias y Agroindustriales Aseguramiento de la propriedad rural y fortalecimiento de servicios agropecuarios. SOUTH AFRICA Free State Rural Development Association Land Restitution to Claimants Communities: Promoting Land Rights. ZAMBIA Zambia Land Alliance Multistakeholder project for a Land Policy Review process. NICARAGUA Supporting rural women by securing their land tenure and their local institutions. For additional information on the CEF programme please visit our website www.landcoalition.org/main_cef.htm. The 6th PAC meeting is scheduled for April 2004. LAND Partnerships for Access to Land in South-East Asia In October 2003, Coalition partners in the Philippines and Indonesia were joined by the secretariat coordinator to initiate the Land Alliances for National Development initiative, or “LAND Partnerships.” Roundtable discussions in the Philippines, co-hosted by the Department for Agrarian Reform (DAR) and the Asian NGO Coalition for Agrarian Reform and Rural Development (ANGOC), resulted in an agreement among key government, civil society, international institutions International Land Coalition www.landcoalition.org – Advancing Together Newsletter No 1 Vol 1 February 2004 4 Advancing Together WOMEN’S ACCESS TO LAND and donors to share their analyses of the current challenges facing the agrarian reform movement. A mapping research study is now underway, a joint effort led by government and civil society to identify common ground in the land policy debate, with a focus on the processes through which agrarian reform is now being implemented. A series of national dialogues is scheduled for July to strengthen working partnerships for implementing access to land programmes, drawing on the mapping study’s findings. In Indonesia, meetings among key government departments and international agencies introduced the Land Coalition’s work at the global level and reviewed existing partnerships between government and civil society, including initiatives by the Consortium for Agrarian Reform (KPA). With a nationwide process now underway to revise the country’s Basic Agrarian Law, KPA and the National Land Agency (BPN) are working with people’s organizations, other government departments, intergovernmental agencies and multi-stakeholder working groups to support citizen participation in revising land and agrarian policies, and to encourage greater policy coordination at the national level. Launched at the WSSD in 2002, LAND Partnerships seeks to enhance collaboration among national governments, civil society and international agencies in their efforts to increase access to land by poor men and women. The Government of the Netherlands is contributing to LAND Partnership pilot activities in four countries, Guatemala, Indonesia, the Philippines and South Africa. There have been more requests and interests for new LAND countries. Governments, donors, NGOs and other partners are encouraged to contact the Land Coalition to join this initiative. For further information contact: [email protected] or [email protected]. WOMEN’S ACCESS TO LAND New Publication: Rural Women’s Access to Land and Property in Selected Countries The International Land Coalition, Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) and International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD) have completed a study on progress in improving women’s access to land, including women’s rights to inherit property. This study is based on the periodic country reports submitted under the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW) from 1997-2003, specifically relating to Article 14 that deals with the status of rural women and Articles 15 and 16 that relates to women’s rights to property, inheritance and access to land. The report is an important resource for people working to advance the rights of women and women’s access to land. CEDAW is the only human rights treaty that deals specifically with rural women and their rights related to the issues of land, development, social services and participation. The document can found on our website www.landcoalition.org/main_re.html Land Coalition Partners Work Together to call for Access for Women Farmers At the International Federation of Agricultural Producers (IFAP) International Conference on Women in Agriculture held in November 2003 in Manila Philippines, Land Coalition partners called for strengthening alliances to increase women farmers’ access to land. (ANGOC) represented the Coalition and noted that while global alliances can be an important tool for building a common platform on women’s access to land, the realities of women farmers at the national and local levels must also be reflected in international women’s platforms. More than 60 women farmers attended the IFAP conference on women in agriculture, for which the main theme was to “empower women farmers for sustainable development.” The final report is available in English and French www.ifap.org/issues/2confwom03/report.html. A Paper was prepared by the Land Coalition Secretariat as a contribution to the discussion, is available at www.landcoalition.org/main_events.htm Land, Water and Gender in Southern Africa The International Land Coalition is supporting a project of the Women's Land and Water Rights in southern Africa, involving analysis of the linkages between land, water, gender and integrated rural development in four Southern African countries; Lesotho, Mozambique, Zambia and Zimbabwe. This initiative is anticipated to provide a regional and Afro-centric perspective and a process that will contribute to ongoing research on integrated water resources management, land and agrarian reform, as well as gender mainstreaming at various levels of policy formulation and implementation. The project outcomes will include national reports from the four countries and case studies on the interplay of regulatory frameworks, laws and policies on land and water and their effect on women’s rights, food security and poverty. Don Marquez, Executive Director of Asian NGO Coalition for Agrarian Reform and Rural Development International Land Coalition www.landcoalition.org – Advancing Together Newsletter No 1 Vol 1 February 2004 5 Advancing Together WORKSHOPS AND CONFERENCES Resultados del Encuentro Internacional de Organizaciones Campesinas y Sociedad Civil “Uso de la Tierra y Desarrollo Económico” Managua Nicaragua 27-29 November 2003 La concentración de la tierra en pocas manos revela inequidad e injusticia social para la mayoría de los productores del campo, pero también ineficiencia económica de la gran empresa agropecuaria. Es un hecho que la producción familiar de pequeña y mediana escala es más eficiente en términos económicos. Esta síntesis quiere presentar los resultados del encuentro de Managua en términos de propuestas y considerando los puntos de vista sea de las organizaciones campesinas que de los organismos internacionales. INICIATIVAS PROPUESTAS POR LOS DIRIGENTES DE LAS ORGANIZACIONES CAMPESINAS PRIORIDADES POR LOS REPRESENTANTES DE LOS ORGANISMOS DE COOPERACIÓN ¿Cómo corregir la concentración de la tierra en pocas manos? Diálogo nacional que contemple • Participación de un grupo mediador idóneo. • Creación de un marco jurídico agrario descentralizado. • Promoción de experiencias exitosas de la agricultura campesina. • Educación y socialización. • Enfoque de género y familia. • • • • • • Marco jurídico adecuado • Incentivo sobre uso adecuado de los recursos. • Control de tierras ociosas. • Impuesto sobre grandes extensiones. • Acceso vía compra de grandes fincas por pequeños productores. Medidas específicas para la administración de la tierra • Formas jurídicas flexibles para la organización • económica de los productores. • • Enfoque integral que propicie la asistencia técnica y • financiera. • Transparencia de registro y catastro. • Educación en derecho agrario. ¿Cómo evitar la reconcentración de tierras en pocas manos? Control social • Diagnóstico del potencial de los suelos, uso actual, distribución y situación legal. • Descentralización en el poder local: consejos comunales y leyes municipales. • • • • Creación de alianzas de ONG en nombre de sus contrapartes. Incidencia sobre los gobiernos del Norte, Banco Mundial y FMI. Apoyar en las diferentes reflexiones y análisis. Promoción de experiencias exitosas de la agricultura campesina. Educación y socialización. Enfoque de género y familia. Asistencia técnica y económica. Formar personas en el campo jurídico (becas). Organizar seminarios para capacitar a los funcionarios del catastro. Realizar un diagnóstico que fundamente el discurso. Apoyo en la actualización del catastro con la participación de los actores locales. Influir en la redacción de la ley municipal. Apoyo en la divulgación y sensibilización a nivel local, nacional e internacional. Otras medidas • Fortalecimiento a las organizaciones campesinas a través de • Fortalecer a organizaciones campesinas de base a nivel proyectos y encuentros. nacional. • Hacer intercambio de experiencias para favorecer el diálogo. • Política fiscal acorde con el desarrollo del campo. • Regular el mercado de tierras tomando en cuenta a las organizaciones. • Control colectivo sobre el uso de la tierra y recursos bajo distintas modalidades. ¿Qué se debe hacer para asegurar la viabilidad de la producción familiar? • • • Conocer el mercado para que la producción responda a la demanda. Definir mecanismos de intercambio basados en la economía solidaria. Desarrollar mercados locales y no sólo de exportación. • • • • • Conseguir cooperación de organismos multilaterales. Apoyar la diversificación de la producción. Apoyo con créditos y asistencia técnica la transformación de los productos. Hacer promoción del comercio justo. Favorecer la cooperación de grupos de consumidores con los productores. International Land Coalition www.landcoalition.org – Advancing Together Newsletter No 1 Vol 1 February 2004 6 Advancing Together WORKSHOPS AND CONFERENCES Regional Conference on Land and the Economy in Nicaragua In November 2003, representatives of more than 100 Central American civil society organizations and academic institutions, along with international and bilateral organisations, took part in a Regional Conference on Land and the Economy. The conference was organised by Unión de Campesinos Organizados de San Dionisio (UCOSD), Matagalpa; Central Cafetalera del Norte (CECOCAFEN), Matagalpa, Cooperativa agropecuaria Rafaela Herrera, Chinandega, Comisión para el desarrollo rural (CODER), Chinandega, Unión de cooperativas de Miraflor (UCA Miraflor), Estelí, Unión Nacional de Agricultores y Ganaderos (UNAG PCAC/Las Segovias). Supporters of the conference included International Land Coalition, European Union, Accion Hambre Centro America, Trocaire, Institut de Recherches et d'Applications des Méthodes de Développement (IRAM), MS Denmark, French Cooperation. The following key issues related to land access in the region were identified: • Legal Security of Tenure is Basic. Support to land mapping and the other elements in the titling processes is essential. This can take various forms and should not only be seen as individual titling of plots. • Contribution of the Peasant Economy. It is necessary to undertake analysis, action research and economic assessments in order to validate the contribution of the peasant economy national economic development. to overall • Dialogue Spaces are Essential. Civil society and farmers organizations see a real need to widen the space in which campesinos and farmers’ needs and concerns can be brought before decision-makers. • Defending Compliance. Governments must be held accountable for decisions they have taken on land issues, particularly those made in international agreements and summits. These include commitments concerning the reform of national laws to protect the rights, access and security of tenure of poor rural households. • Land Reform has a Human Face. The struggles and human violations that have and continue to occur need to be told within and outside the region. The abuse of peoples’ rights to the level of significant numbers of murders should not remain silenced. The conference included direct testimonials by Central American campesinas and farmers, and presentations on the comparative experiences of increasing access to land in Central America and in Europe. A formal conference report is being prepared by the organizers, based on the debate and synthesis sessions at the conference. The overall theme for this conference was access to land and economic development, or “uso de la tierra y desarrollo economico.” Additional information on the conference is available from our website Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues Workshop at IFAD The International Land Coalition chairs the round table on “Access to land and related resources” On 15th December 2003, a one-day workshop with four members of the Permanent Forum of Indigenous People was held at International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD) in collaboration with the Department of External Affairs of IFAD, the International Land Coalition and the Global Mechanism. The hosts of the convention to combat desertification joined IFAD staff to share information about the mandate, scope of work and programmes of the Forum and to familiarize themselves about the work of IFAD and partner agencies related to indigenous issues. In the workshop, the Land Coalition secretariat discussed the numerous links between securing access to land and indigenous peoples’ issues. Highlighting the Land Coalition demand-driven and bottom-up approach in dealing with indigenous peoples’ matters and land related issues, the Secretariat presented case-studies from its partners’ experiences within the CEF Programme: 1. The Amerindian Peoples Association in Guyana aim to obtain recognition of land titles for eight indigenous communities in Guyana, where a longstanding conflict between mining companies and indigenous communities is occurring. 2. The Philippine Association for Intercultural Development’s successful experience of 3-D mapping ancestral domains is supporting indigenous communities in filing their legal claims to land. 3. The Cameroon project supporting groups of Bagyeli pygmies in conflict resolution with Bantu communities, who also depend on the same natural resources. 4. The Codeca (Asociación Comité de Desarrollo Campesino) - Guatemala project establishing a juridical office to help in land conflict resolution involving indigenous communities. The workshop represented an important opportunity to explore the form and nature that may be given to a relationship between the Land Coalition and indigenous peoples and these organisations. More information on the Permanent forum on Indigenous Peoples’ can be found on http://www.un.org/esa/socdev/pfii/ International Land Coalition www.landcoalition.org – Advancing Together Newsletter No 1 Vol 1 February 2004 7 WORKSHOPS AND CONFERENCES Advancing Together Land Issues in Poverty Reduction Stategy Papers (PRSPs) LandNet West Africa, October 03, Lome Togo Support to LandNet West Africa Sub-Regional Capacity Building Workshop on Land Issues in the PRSPs held in Togo in October 2003 enabled the LandNet West Africa country focal points from Burkina Faso, Ghana, Guinea, Mali, Niger, Nigeria, Senegal and Togo to adopt a work plan for the next three years. Furthermore the workshop presented an opportunity for the members of the network to prepare and coordinate NGO perspectives and positions addressed to the governments attending the Regional Forum on Rural Land Tenure and Sustainable Development (Praia+9) held in Bamako in November 2003. A copy of the report can be requested from Mr Hubert Ouedraogo at: [email protected] Didi Odigie and Jerome Gefu (Nigeria), Jean Pierre-Condé (Guinée), Larbi Odame and Mark Yeboah (Ghana) Informe final del Taller – Territorio y Desarrollo sostenible en América Latina y Caribe Colombia, 17-20 de junio de 2003 El tema del ordenamiento territorial en sus varias apelaciones está cobrando cada día más importancia y esto se debe a varias razones: (i) por un lado, el tema general del acceso a la tierra se ha presentado de nuevo en la agenda de un número muy elevado de países, paralelamente a una reconcentración de la tierra a niveles iguales si no superiores a lo que se constataban 40 años atrás, en el auge de la época de las reformas agrarias; (ii) por otro lado, la multidimensionalidad de las actividades realizadas en los territorios rurales y peri rurales ha llevado a buscar soluciones al problema agrario en un conjunto de actividades no solamente de tipo agrícola y/o rural; (iii) la poca valencia de los abordajes del pasado, de tipo estatalista o mercantilista, están abriendo la puerta a una necesidad nueva de búsqueda de un abordaje más pragmático (menos ideológico), más centrado en los recursos humanos disponibles y que operan en el territorio. Dos vertientes se han venido diseñando al respecto del tema territorial: los que privilegian un abordaje de tipo geográfico-planificatorio centrados en las funciones administrativas que el Estado descentralizado debería cumplir. Por el otro lado tenemos los que parten de un análisis distinto, donde la centralidad no es el territorio sino los problemas concretos, a su distinta escala, que los actores encuentran en el acceso, uso y gestión del recurso territorial. La dimensión cada día más presente con estos problemas es la creciente falta de confianza en las instituciones que deberían ayudar en la solución del problema. La conflictividad en el campo va aumentando, los recursos son cada día más escasos así como se hacen mas débiles las capacidades del Estado, en sus centros locales, dar respuesta a estos problemas: lo que cada día más se contesta es la capacidad misma del Estado de articular intereses individuales con prioridades de la colectividad de ciudadanos, o sea su papel de mediador y articulador de intereses. Es por eso que es importante el restablecimiento de confianza cobra su legitimidad en cuanto es uno de los motores del abordaje territorial hoy en día en la región. En la discusión final en plenaria los organizadores del taller evidenciaron las principales perspectivas de trabajo al interno de las propias organizaciones y en red con las instituciones presentes; en primer lugar Annalisa Mauro, en nombre de la Coalición, y Paolo Groppo, como representante FAO, evidenciaron la importancia de dirigir las acciones a un apoyo al dialogo social, al apoderamiento de las organizaciones de base y de los actores más débiles y a la capacitación (también de las administraciones locales), para aumentar el poder contractual y fortalecer los procesos y las propuestas desde abajo. Paolo Groppo y Federica Ravera International Land Coalition www.landcoalition.org – Advancing Together Newsletter No 1 Vol 1 February 2004 8 NEWS FROM COALITION PARTNERS Advancing Together Social Development Foundation (SDF) “We are here working hard on the project at Mau and recently organised a workshop in Delhi to chalk out a future strategy. The wonderful part of it was that a fairly large number of women participated. Now they want participation in development. The Mau project has opened avenues for fisherfolks, their women and small farmers. You will be very pleased to hear that the farmers here are so happy with us that I cannot narrate. About 5000 acres of land has been inundated in water and now the farmers are in full support of SDF and the Land Coalition. From Mau, we will build a strong farmers movement in Uttar-Pradesh. I am looking beyond the CEF and now interested in strengthening the land partnership issue in Uttar-Pradesh with active participation of women. The next digging and cleaning phase will start in February/March. The CEF has given hope to thousands of fishermen and farmers in terms of awareness it generated. We on our part fought this battle on both developmental as well as ideological perception. We were clearer about our target. We know people need development and hence it was natural for them to be with us. VB Rawat” Workshop on women empowerment (by staff reporter) http://www.hindu.com/2004/02/09/stories/2004020908610300.htm NEW DELHI, FEB. 8. A two-day workshop to strengthen the participation of women in the developmental work of Taal Ratoy in the Mau district of Uttar-Pradesh was organised here recently by the Delhi-based Social Development Foundation in which a number of fisher-folks, both men and women, along with small farmers participated. The workshop was part of a two-year long developmental work initiated by SDF with the help of International Land Coalition, Rome, under their Community Empowerment Facility programme. The CEF programme is a one-time aid for communities to help them come up with their own solutions and reap the benefit of development. In Mau, Taal Ratoy is huge lake spread over about 1,500 acres of which about 750 acres is under the legal rights of the 22 Gaon Machchua Mallah Samiti which represents the fishermen community. Their condition is dismal in the area with the lake not being taken care of properly. The project initiated by the SDF is using the indigenous knowledge of the fishermen community in developing the lake. After it is deepened and cleaned, good fish production would be ensured here through a fishermen's co-operative. The entire project has been formulated by the fishermen community. "Mere forming of cooperatives will not work unless women's participation is also ensured. The condition of women is worst among the fishermen community of Mau and they are just confined to their households. Hence to ensure their participation, special awareness efforts have been launched including a small school for girls which runs under the shade of the tree. SDF has also been able to form an organization of the fishermen named as Tal Ratoy Machchua Jan Kalyan Samiti and formation of women's groups in the area is also in the process,'' said Vidya Bhushan Rawat, Director, SDF. The women who participated in the Delhi workshop have never travelled outside their area before and it was, therefore, a great opportunity for them. Many spoke about their problems and sang songs in Bhojpuri to narrate the pathetic condition of their community including violence, dowry and alcoholism. Some spoke about creating alternative employment so that they get an opportunity to interact and speak. Seema Rajbhar mentioned that when she started cycling in the village areas every one would stare at her. Her husband would not allow her to go out for work. But it was her determination which ultimately prevailed. Indira Singh wanted that women be given equal opportunity so that they can prove themselves. International Land Coalition www.landcoalition.org – Advancing Together Newsletter No 1 Vol 1 February 2004 9 NEWS FROM COALITION PARTNERS Advancing Together Transborder Wildlife (TWA) in Albania sharing information with Association for the Protection of Landowners Rights (APLR) in Georgia The following is an example of knowledge exchange between two Land Coalition partners, Transborder Wildlife (TWA) in Albania and the Association for the Protection of Landowners Rights (APLR) in Georgia. Both organizations are actively supporting rural households to increase their secure access to forest land and resources. This letter from Stavri Pllaha of TWA identifies several challenges and lessons identified through the group’s experiences in Albania. “Dear Jaba, Congratulations to APLR for starting the implementation of the project titled: “Endowment for Community Mobilization Initiatives in Western Georgia” . After reading your project proposal I see that there are many similarities between Albania and Georgia relating to land reform and development of the community in decision making. During a 2 year period, through the support of the International Land Coalition, TWA carried out a wide campaign to raise the public awareness in forest and pasture land management capacity. During the first step peasants elected their commissions in each village, which led them in the whole process of forest and pasture transfer. For the establishment of village commissions, open meetings were held in each village. TWA helped each community to organize the meeting but didn’t impact in the election of the commissions. TWA was a facilitator only. The village commissions were established in all villages. During the past months the village’s commissions with the assistance of TWA, defined the village’s confines as well, which are signed by elders of each neighbouring village. TWA explained the law and regulations on forest and pasture transfer in use by communes and the procedures that must lead the whole process, since the establishment of village commissions for the registration of forestland. We worked on the preparation of a forest management plan, distribution of future commune forest after forest users (family or group families) and registration of forest land. TWA in collaboration with Forest Service and villages commissions finished the forest management plan. Forest Service, commune and local people were involved in the preparation of the commune forest management plan. The establishment of CBO was very important for the success of our project in the future. Forest Users Association was established and registered in Court as a legal organization. Forest Users Association as a legal organization has to lead the community in forest and pasture process in the future. For the establishment of CBO it is very important that the leadership must be elected directly by the community. During the establishment of CBO we encountered problems for the election of the leaders of CBO. Local governance officials tried to intervene during the election of CBO leaders. Some of them wanted people who were close to them to be elected. It was a serious obstacle for the success of the project and the future of CBO. We tried to persuade the community that they must persist. The leaders of the CBO will be their leaders and they must be elected by them. After a lot of contacts, meetings and discussions we tried to persuade them that CBO will be their organization and CBO will represent them. So, it was very important that the community had to elect their leaders by themselves. We think the establishment of CBO must be considered seriously as the first step. For the Establishment of CBO we realized: • A lot of contacts and meetings with local people, where village commissions played an important role. • Preparation of the statute and approval by Forest Users Association. • Election of CBO leaders by the community. • Registration of Forest Users Association in Court and opening of a Bank account. • 2 training sessions with Forest Users Association. Other problems encountered during project implementation There were conflicts for forest confines after families. Many families didn’t agree with each other etc. Some other families fear to use the forest, thinking they cannot protect it from illegal cutting, paying different taxes etc. TWA organized open meetings in each village especially in the villages where there were problems. TWA explained that there are no taxes or other similar problems but using the forest makes their future better. Another problem during the implementation of the project was the registration of forestland. The Real Estate Registration Office didn’t agree to register the forestland for use by peasants. The reason was because in Albania the state property (including state forest) is not registered yet. So, it was impossible to register forestland for use by peasants unless the state forestland is not registered. Transborder Wildlife contacted the peasants and organized a workshop with commune officials and representatives of indigenous people to resolve that problem. Local people agreed that it would be very important for them to have a legal certificate from the Commune. For that purpose we involved the commune officials to work for the registration of forestland of the peasants and preparation of legal certificate, which were signed by the Mayor. International Land Coalition www.landcoalition.org – Advancing Together Newsletter No 1 Vol 1 February 2004 10 Advancing Together NEWS FROM COALITION PARTNERS LESSONS LEARNT • Through the implementation of the project we tried to learn how to build new policies and actions which could diminish the poverty and stimulate increased productivity. We learnt the main factors that lead to successful results in forest transfer for use by local people are: In Albania agricultural land distribution finished ten years ago. The agricultural land is almost fully privatized. The peasants have access to use and maintain agricultural land but they are still poor, especially in mountainous areas. The reasons are: • The land is insufficient. • The land is poor. • The land is fragmentized. • There is no irrigation system. • It is very difficult to use machinery and other equipment. So, other alternatives related to natural resources and land reform must be implemented. For mountainous areas Forest and Pasture Land Reform is very important. In this framework communal forestry and pasture (in use of community) must be taken into consideration. The best steps to succeed were: • • Contacting communities to know old traditions (before socialism time) of indigenous people in forest and pasture management Establishment of forest and pasture commissions for each village which will be responsible for distribution of forest and pasture (the community of the villages elected the village’s commissions). Studying the social economic situation of local people (land use, agriculture and husbandry, other economic activities in the area, infrastructure and natural resources). • Inciting the decision making of indigenous people. It is very important that communities participate in the whole process of forest transfer. • Partnership and accountability among the all groups. • Establishment by communities of CBO to lead them in the future. Better participation of the community in decision-making ensures easier implementation of successful Land Reform. Some constraints and obstacles for us, which must be considered in the future: • The actual communal forestry policy is too centralized. • The lack of legal acts and regulations for communal forestry. • Barriers and limitations on the rights of forest users with reference to exploit forest and other natural resources. • Obstacles caused by Real Estate Registration Office. I hope we will have to share more information and experience during the implementation of your project. Regards, Stavri Pllaha Transborder Wildlife (TWA)” PARTNERS’ PUBLICATIONS Recent Publications available from our Partners which have been supported by the International Land Coalition The People’s Campaign for Agrarian Reform Network (AR Now!) Quezon City, The Philippines Copies available from: [email protected] or [email protected] Land Advocacy in the Philippines AR Now! Experiences and Learnings December 2003 Mainstreaming the People’s Agenda Advocacy Handbook for Agrarian Reform and Rural Development October 2003 Women’s Environment and Development Organisation (WED)) New York, USA Copies available from [email protected] Common Ground Women’s Access to Natural Resources and the United Nations Millennium Development Goals December 2003 International Land Coalition www.landcoalition.org – Advancing Together Newsletter No 1 Vol 1 February 2004 11 Advancing Together LAND COALITION PUBLICATIONS AND WEBSITE LAND COALITION PUBLICATIONS Email us [email protected] for an order form for the following publications: Land Alliances for National Development 18 pg En/Sp the International Land Coalition 68 pg Ar/En/Fr/Sp Available Now! Women’s Resource Access Programme Voices from the Field in Cambodia – 16 pgs It is the 4th in a series of publications sponsored by the Government of Japan Towards a Common Platform on Access to Land 20 pg En/Sp Voices from the field – WRAP Women’s Resource Access Programme – English only Cambodia 16 pg, India 16 pg Indonesia 12 pg, Nepal 12 pg Whose Land 253 pg English Plus limited quantities of: Cloth bags, baseball caps and lapel pins WHAT’S NEW IN THE WEB EVENTS - IFAP International Conference on Women in Agriculture - Advocacy Events - ECOSOC Ministerial Roundtable and final report NEWS Signing of Land Partnership Protocol Philippines International Land Coalition enters formal agreement with Minister for Development Cooperation of the Netherlands to develop LAND Partnership New CEF Profiles Regional Summary ASIA Platform on Women’s Land and Water Rights in Southern Africa International Land Coalition IFAD Via del Serafico, 107 Rome 00142 Italy Tel: 39 06 5459 2445 Fax: 39 06 504 3463 Email: [email protected] Website: www.coalition.org WEBSITE NEWS Forum In response to the feedback we received from our recent website survey, we are currently developing a forum whereby members will have a space in our website to place news, events or interesting topics for discussion. Members’ messages posted in this space will be available to anyone who accesses our website. Our first use of this new medium will be with the Consultation of the EU Land Policy Guidelines. Members and Partners can send comments about the document to [email protected] where we will assemble them for public viewing on our forum. The Forum and related documents are on our home page. www.landcoalition.org/ updated February 2004 FORUM (home page) – Consultation on the draft Land Policy Guidelines of the EU (English/French/Spanish) Email us your comments and contributions [email protected] CONTACT US COALITION SECRETARIAT Bruce Moore, Coordinator Annalisa Mauro, Programme Officer Jing de la Rosa, Advocacy and LAND Partnerships Programme Officer Andrew Fuys, Visiting Fellow – Policy and Programme Development Julie Carle, Communications Officer Barbara Codispoti, Assistant Programme Officer Charlotte Pedersen, Assistant Programme Officer Lucia Angelucci, Programme Assistant Alessandra Goberti, Administration Clerk Stefano Digessa, Intern NEWSLETTER EDITORIAL COMMITTEE Advancing Together is published each February, June and October. Copies can be seen on our website www.landcoalition.org/main_re.html. Please distribute copies of our newsletter to interested parties. The newsletter has been compiled by our editorial committee – Julie Carle, Andrew Fuys and Charlotte Pedersen. Contributions from members and partners for our June edition are welcome and must be received before 10th May. Please email us at [email protected] with your comments and articles. International Land Coalition www.landcoalition.org – Advancing Together Newsletter No 1 Vol 1 February 2004 12